Login  /  Register  | 1 premium articles left before you must register.
TheDay.com - A great way to start the day at Shelter Harbor Inn | Southeastern Connecticut News, Sports, Weather and Video | The Day newspaper

A great way to start the day at Shelter Harbor Inn

By Michael Costanza

Publication: The Day

Published 11/26/2009 12:00 AM
Updated 11/30/2009 05:03 AM

Happy Thanksgiving. Today is for family and football, but tomorrow morning - once you've had your fill of turkey and turnips, the in-laws, and dirty dishes - why not treat yourself to a relaxing breakfast?

Long known for its elegant dinners, the Shelter Harbor Inn in Westerly serves all three meals 365 days a year. Overnight guests eat breakfast free, but for $8 to $10 the public can order from the same menu, which features delicious, creative renditions of traditional favorites.

The eggs Benedict ($10) have always impressed me, and this time was no different. Mine arrived at the table hot, two eggs perfectly poached, the yolks bursting at the touch of my fork onto thick slabs of Canadian bacon and buttered and browned English muffins, all topped with a hollandaise sauce.

The sauce - creamy rather than frothy, buttery and only slightly tangy, abundant but not smothering - makes this dish without obscuring the other ingredients. I mopped up the last of it and the yolk with a slice of sourdough toast borrowed from my friend's plate.

We ate in the inn's central dining room, basking in the Sunday morning sunlight from the window beside us and inhaling the comforting autumn scent of the stone fireplace. Part of the original early 19th-century farmhouse, the room is bright with a blonde hardwood floor and white linens and cloth napkins on each table.

Our waiter greeted us with a plate of three gingerbread raisin scones, which were moist and chewy - a nice touch you won't find at your neighborhood diner. You pay a little more to eat in such a setting, but the atmosphere nonetheless remains casual.

Our waiter was a little slow to refill water glasses and forgot to bring sugar for our coffee, but he was polite and talkative, and he patiently got answers to every one of our questions.

Most of those questions were about the quiche of the day ($10). This was not the fluffy, cheesy variety served as a side at so many office banquets. This quiche stood about four inches tall, a hearty meal in its own right, a dense slice that brought to mind the original meaning of the word "quiche" - from the German "Kuchen," or cake. The inside oozed with a mildly smoky, sharp provolone and contained asparagus and chorizo. (It needed more chorizo.)

The best part was the crust - a dense and thick layer of rolled oats, slightly crunchy, that reminded me of homemade bread. It was vastly superior to the typical pastry crust, so often soggy and undercooked, that gives quiche a bad name. This was a quiche a man could order with no shame.

We also enjoyed the Boursin cheese omelet ($9). The cheese tasted so rich and creamy, it really didn't matter that it was also filled with apple-smoked bacon and caramelized onions. Shoe leather would taste great with Boursin cheese. The omelet was one egg too small, however. All of our breakfasts came with homefries, which were simple, pan-roasted redskins. The serving size should be doubled. The omelet and quiche each came with a choice of toast.

My friends and I saved a fourth plate for "dessert," the banana walnut French toast ($9). This dish was predictably sweet and syrupy, topped with caramelized banana slices and walnut halves. It featured thick slices of French bread moist and hot on the inside with a crunchy fried coating of corn flakes on the outside.

Eating it was like eating a glazed doughnut, only so much better. It could hold its own against the most sinful of French toast concoctions at your favorite diner, especially if the serving were bigger and it came with more than just two strips of crispy bacon.

At any rate, I am thrilled that we discovered the wonders of ordering a "dessert breakfast" and kicking myself for not thinking of it years ago.

MORE

SHELTER HARBOR INN

10 Wagner Road, Westerly
(401) 322-8883
www.shelterharborinn.com

Hours: 365 days a year - breakfast 7:30 to 11:30 a.m., lunch 11:30 a.m. to 4 p.m., dinner 4 to 10 p.m., Sunday brunch 11:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m.

Cuisine: Creative renditions of traditional American favorites.

Prices: Breakfasts $8 to $10; lunches $9 to $21; dinners $10 to $28; soups, salads, and appetizers $4 to $12.

Atmosphere: Elegant but casual, a New England country inn in an early 19th-century farmhouse with additions. Some hardwood floors and fireplaces, a sun-lit bar.

Service: Friendly, adequate, a little distracted on this visit.

Reservations: Recommended for dinner.

Credit cards: All major.

Handicapped access: A few steps up from the front door.

Town News

Visit Zip06
Submit Your:  Submit Your News Submit Your Photos Submit Your Events
Most Recent Poll

Read the transcript of the chat with New London Mayor Finizio

The Day hosted a web chat with New London Mayor Daryl J. Finizio to discuss the beginning of his new administration and news out of the city's police department.