Log In


Reset Password
  • MENU
    Editorials
    Thursday, April 25, 2024

    Trump's no Reagan on trusting free market

    This editorial appeared in Friday’s Washington Post.

    If the Republican Party has stood for anything in recent decades, it is the idea that no one in government, not even the most brilliant of presidents, can allocate society’s resources more efficiently than what President Ronald Reagan called “the magic of the marketplace.” As it happens, the GOP was broadly correct about that.

    So of all the changes President-elect Donald Trump has brought to his party and, possibly, to policy, none is more potentially radical than his apparent belief that it will be up to him, as president, to order businesses to do what he thinks is in the national interest, or else.

    Nor is it clear whether Trump himself is operating according to a coherent plan of action, much less a coherent theory of corporate responsibility. When he picked United Technologies’ Carrier plant in Indiana as a whipping boy because of its plans to shift production to Mexico, he randomly ignored a neighboring factory that was about to do the same. And when a local union official called Trump a liar and said he exaggerated how many Carrier jobs were being saved, Trump retaliated by blaming the union–not callous management, as he had previously–for the fact that “companies flee country,” as he put it on Twitter.

    Meanwhile, Trump commenced to bash another company, Boeing, for purportedly overcharging the government for next-generation Air Force One planes. The president-elect’s comments, accompanied, like his attack on United Technologies, by a threat against Boeing’s government contracts, came suspiciously soon after Boeing’s chief executive had offered a measured critique of Trumpian trade policy, though Trump denied a connection.

    This is the sort of strong-arming that Republicans rightly condemned when Presidents John F. Kennedy and Lyndon B. Johnson tried to order price cuts in, respectively, steel and color televisions, supposedly to control inflation. It not only threatens the politicization of investment, one of the worst, most corrupting ills that can befall a market economy. Trump’s blunt-force manipulation of business also is doomed to fail.

    Reining in a president determined to abuse his power in this way is a job for Congress, dominated by Republicans, and they will do it, unless all that talk about free enterprise, property rights and “the magic of the marketplace” was just talk.

    Comment threads are monitored for 48 hours after publication and then closed.