Log In


Reset Password
  • MENU
    Op-Ed
    Saturday, April 20, 2024

    If Net Neutrality dies, the Internet dies too

    Do you like paying more for less? If so, then you’re going to love President Trump’s plan to eliminate Net Neutrality! For those unfamiliar with the term, it basically means that an internet service provider can’t slow or block your bandwidth to certain websites, nor can they charge you extra fees for access to certain parts of the internet.

    It is this philosophy, codified into sensible regulations supported close to unanimously by the tech industry, which  allows you to freely navigate the internet. It allows consumers to subscribe to any video streaming service they want instead of being forced to use the one provided by your cable company. It’s what protects small business owners from having to pay a ransom to every major ISP in the country to keep their websites from being blocked or slowed.

    Net Neutrality may not be around for much longer, though, if the telecom industry and its lapdogs in Congress get their way. The rules that protect us from abusive practices are in the process of being repealed by the new FCC. There is no overstating the disastrous effects this will have on our economy – with the exception of the telecom giants, who stand to profit immensely. Congress has the power to prevent this by passing Net Neutrality legislation, but they have thus far failed to take any action.

    Unsurprisingly, the telecom companies have poured hundreds of millions of dollars into abolishing Net Neutrality. They claim they’re motivated only by an altruistic belief that outdated regulations are bad and that this has nothing to do with maximizing profits. In other words, they think we’re idiots.

    Let’s say that car companies were allowed to charge you extra for driving to certain destinations. Better yet, they can charge you for driving to any destination not on a predetermined list. You’d still own the car, but you’d have to keep paying the people you bought it from every time you drive it. Does that sound fair?

    The car will probably still take you to your destination, though the onboard computer has been programmed to not let you drive faster than 15 miles per hour until you pay the ransom. They wouldn’t call it a ransom, of course; they’d call it an "optional upgrade," even though they’re not actually providing any additional services or features. Fortunately, unlike the telecom companies, America’s auto makers have had the good sense not to attempt such a greedy and ill-conceived power grab.

    Without Net Neutrality, companies like Verizon will be allowed to massively slow your internet speeds any time you access sites that you haven’t paid then extra for. Worse still, they’ll be able to block all of their customers’ access to any website that either competes with them or refuses to pay a ransom.

    For example, Comcast might decide to severely throttle (slow) or outright block their subscribers’ access to Netflix, Hulu, and Prime Video while giving preference to their own streaming video platform. And if The Day or some other news organization were to publish an article criticizing any of the major telecom companies, they’d risk losing most of their website traffic and ad revenue, which could lead to a chilling effect on journalists. These are just some examples of the kinds of abuses that will happen if Congress allows Net Neutrality to be repealed.

    Kris Craig is a software engineer. He lives in College Place, Washington.

    Comment threads are monitored for 48 hours after publication and then closed.