On the Side: Old Mystic General Store pizza

Dan Gaiewski, an 18-year-old senior at Fitch High School, told me that the best pizza in Connecticut is at the Old Mystic General Store in Old Mystic. Yeah, I thought to myself, sure. Dan said the owner had worked at Pepe’s. Yeah, I thought. Like every chef in America says he used to work for Tom Keller at the French Laundry in Napa.

About three weeks ago, I ordered a small tomato pie. I thought maybe the owner did work for Pepe’s, since Pepe’s does make a tomato pie. It was beyond delicious. A week ago I ordered a large Margarita pie (tomato sauce, mozz and basil, which is, to me, the only way to judge a pizza). I took it to friends in Norwich. We finished it darn quick. The crust is perfect, the tomato sauce sweet and zippy, the mozzarella not overdone and the basil fresh, although I would put it atop a blistering pizza instead of in the oven. It was as good as a Pepe’s pizza. And the place serves grinders and paninis, too. Thanks, Dan.

Old Mystic General Store

47 Main St., Old Mystic

(860) 245-5533


Loading comments...
Hide Comments

Stories that may interest you

Salem Lions host a fun-filled day for the whole family

April 13 was a busy day for the town of Salem, with the Lions 5K and Fun Run in the morning and an Easter egg hunt and jellybean run in the afternoon.

Friends and Neighbors: ELHS freshman tops in regional gymnastics event

East Lyme High School freshman Madeline Fraser competed April 13-14 at the Level 8 Regional Gymnastics Championships in Springfield, Mass., placing first all-around in her age group, scoring a 38.225.

Turning 'darkness into light': Students share Holocaust survivors' stories

Area students shared Holocaust survivors' stories in a ceremony at Waterford High School on Wednesday as part of the Jewish Federation of Eastern Connecticut's Encountering Survivors program.

Re-anchoring the square

Workers from Mystic Shipyard re-install the restored anchor at Liberty Pole Square in Mystic Wednesday.