The dangerous seduction of 'back to normal'
"Life is going to return to normal," President-elect Joe Biden promised last week in a Thanksgiving address to the nation. He was talking about life after COVID-19, but you could be forgiven if you thought he was also making a promise about life after Donald Trump.
It's almost impossible to separate the two. To the extent that voters gave Biden a mandate, it was to end both scourges and make America normal again.
Despite the grim resurgence of COVID-19, Dr. Anthony Fauci, the public health official Trump ignored and then muzzled, and with whom Biden's staff is now conferring, sounded guardedly optimistic last week. He said vaccines will allow "a gradual accrual of more normality as the weeks and the months go by as we get well into 2021."
Normal. You could almost hear America's giant sigh of relief, similar to the one felt when Trump implicitly conceded the election by allowing the transition to begin. It is comforting to think of both COVID-19 and Trump as intrusions into normality, aberrations from routines that prevailed before.
When Biden entered the presidential race last year, he said history would look back on Trump as an "aberrant moment in time." The end of both aberrations — Trump and the outbreak — conjures up a former America that, by contrast, might appear quiet and safe, even boring. Trump called Biden "the most boring human being I've ever seen," and Americans seem to be just fine with that.
Biden's early choices for his Cabinet and senior staff fit the same mold — "all boring picks," tweeted the Atlantic's Graeme Wood, referring to Biden's foreign policy team, "who, if you shook them awake and appointed them in the middle of the night at any time in the last decade, could have reported to their new jobs and started work competently by dawn." Hallelujah.
All of Biden's designees, including Janet Yellen for Treasury secretary and Antony Blinken for secretary of state, are experienced and competent, so refreshing after Trump's goon squads. And they're acceptable both to mainstream Democrats and to progressives. They stand out for their abilities not to stand out. There is no firebrand among them, no Elizabeth Warren or Bernie Sanders (at least not so far).
For the same reasons, they're unlikely to stir strong opposition from Republicans, a necessity for Senate confirmation, particularly if Democrats fail to win the two Senate runoffs in Georgia on Jan. 5.
And they're unlikely to demand much attention from an exhausted and divided public.
Boring, reassuring, normal; these are Biden's great strengths. But he needs to be careful. They could also be his great weaknesses. That's because any return to "normal" would be disastrous for America.
Normal led to Trump. Normal led to the coronavirus. Normal is four decades of stagnant wages and widening inequality when almost all economic gains went to the top. Normal is 40 years of shredded safety nets, and the most expensive but least adequate health care system in the modern world. Normal is growing corruption of politics by big money and an economic system rigged by and for the wealthy. Normal is worsening police brutality. Normal is climate change now verging on catastrophe. Normal is a GOP that for years has been actively suppressing minority votes and embracing white supremacists. Normal is a Democratic Party that for years has been abandoning the working class.
Given the road we were on, Trump and COVID-19 were not aberrations. They were inevitabilities. The moment we are now in — with Trump virtually gone, Biden assembling his Cabinet, and most of the nation starting to feel a bit of relief — is a temporary reprieve.
If the underlying trends don't change, after Biden we could have Trumps as far as the eye can see. And health and environmental crises that make the coronavirus just another step toward Armageddon.
Hence the paradox. America wants to return to a reassuring normal, but Biden can't allow it. Complacency would be deadly. He has to both calm the waters and stir the pot. It's a mistake to see this challenge as placating the progressive wing of the Democratic Party. It's about dealing with problems that have worsened for decades and if left unattended much longer will be enormously destructive.
So the central question: In an exhausted and divided America that desperately wants a return to normal, can Biden find the energy and political will for bold changes that are imperative?
Robert Reich is a former U.S. Secretary of Labor and professor of public policy at Berkeley. His columns are distributed by the Tribune Content Agency.
Stories that may interest you
A committee created to improve police and community relations has morphed into a group that spends its meetings attacking the police and their union leadership.
If they were committed to democracy, CEOs of big corporations would cease corporate donations to all candidates, close their political action committees, and stop giving to "dark money" groups.