Judge past leaders in context of times they lived in
No thoughtful American could observe the events of the last few months and not be horrified at the sight of young Black men and women being murdered by rogue police officers. That behavior is reprehensible and should be repudiated in the courts. Does it justify the renaming of streets and the removal of statues? Yes and no.
The distinction? Civil War-era politicians and generals fought to destroy the union in order to preserve slavery. Why anyone would think memorializing these men was a good idea is incomprehensible. George Washington and Thomas Jefferson? They institutionalized democracy at a time when it did not exist. It is true that it was imperfectly applied because people of color, and women, were excluded until much later.
Washington and Jefferson were products of their times. Context is important. Slavery was normal in the late 1790s. Reprehensible but normal. Erasing the memory of the people responsible for development of a government that still aspires to be "of the people, by the people and for the people" would be wrong. Let's hope honoring those men for the goodness of their body of work, while acknowledging the limitations of their times, shall never perish from the Earth.
Stories that may interest you
In family court we routinely make one parent superior to the other with terms like custodial parent and financially with terms like obligee and obligor concerning child support. On its surface child support seems like a perfectly reasonable idea, but in practice what it does is drive one parent...
Thank you for the July 1 editorial on the Supreme Court's recent decision on abortion and your prediction that the battle will rage on, “Roberts chose precedent, but that...
After living in Tacoma-Pierce County Washington for 10 years, my wife and I moved to Connecticut in 2015. Pierce County was the last county in Washington to change to all mail-in ballots for all elections. Although Washington is a Blue state like Connecticut, there are plenty of Republicans...
Pressure to remove time-honored statues of important figures of American history reveals we are in an era of reevaluating our national heritage and the meaning of being an American. When based on rational debate, such introspection is much needed and productive. But when driven by impulse,...