Log in | Register | Get Home Delivery | Advertise | Mobile
Preferred text size: Small | Default | Large
March 16, 2010

Blumenthal off base criticizing Lyme guidelines

By ANNE GERSHON

Publication: The Day

Published 08/03/2009 12:00 AM
Updated 08/03/2009 10:27 AM

We could not disagree more with the inaccurate statements made by Connecticut Attorney General Richard Blumenthal in his opinion piece on our Lyme disease guidelines ("Conflicts of interest in treatment guidelines," July 19).

The physicians and scientists who wrote the Infectious Disease Society of America's (ISDA) guidelines thoroughly reviewed all the medical evidence and took great care to address the claims made by the small minority of physicians who advocate long-term antibiotic use. Their conclusion, based on several peer-reviewed studies, was that long-term antibiotics are unnecessary and potentially harmful.

The notion that the authors had financial conflicts of interest is absurd to anyone who has read the guidelines, which recommend generic tests and a short course of generic drugs. If the authors were seeking to profit financially, it would have made more sense for them to recommend a lengthy course of treatment and a broader definition of the disease.

Ironically, Mr. Blumenthal and those who criticize IDSA guidelines would increase profits for pharmaceutical companies and revenues for physicians who treat Lyme disease. Mr. Blumenthal's investigation of IDSA ended without filing any legal complaint, and the agreement (not a settlement) that he signed stipulated that IDSA guidelines remain in place. The agreement called for a special review, which is currently under way.

IDSA's signing the agreement was not, as he alleges, an admission of guilt, but an effort to end a fruitless investigation that was costing our organization (and presumably Connecticut taxpayers) thousands of dollars. We hope the review will put to rest the tired old allegations and put the focus where it belongs: making sure that people with Lyme disease get treatment that is safe, effective, and supported by sound medical evidence.

Editor's note: The writer, a physician, is president of the Infectious Diseases Society of America.

Town News

Visit Zip06

The return of the Peeps contest

Once again this year, The Day is running its Peeps competition, in which we invite you to take Easter's favorite candy – Peeps – and turn them into art.

Most Recent Poll
Do you think you'll take advantage of the cash for clunkers program?
Yes
45%
No
55%
Number of votes: 20

Chat with Realtor John Bolduc

John Bolduc, Chief Executive Officer for the Eastern Connecticut Association of Realtors, headquartered in Norwich, will take questions from readers in a live online chat from noon to 2 p.m., Tuesday.

Who would you give your prize money to?

President Barack Obama plans to donate the $1.4 million from his Nobel Peace Prize to helping students, veterans' families and survivors of Haiti's earthquake, among others. Who would you give your...