Slow-cooker pot roast, when only meat will do

Slow-cooker Pot Roast with carrots, onions and pureed cauliflower.

It’s ridiculous to say, but the biggest obstacle in my quest to eat more healthy foods that have a lower impact on the planet is my love of meat. Big hunks of red meat, in particular. 

It seems as though when my diet consists mainly of vegetables, grains, beans, eggs and poultry, there always comes a day when I just have to have some meat. 

Sometimes the craving can be satisfied by the flavor and very little of the actual meat. A beef noodle soup, for example, or a stir-fry or fajitas or a salad topped with a bit of grilled meat can take care of it. But then there are days when all I want is pot roast. 

Pot roast is basically a long, slow braise of a tough but flavorful cut of beef (my memere would have used pork). The slow cooking breaks down all the resilient, connective tissue that characterizes these cuts – chuck, brisket, shoulder – resulting in tender, succulent meat and a very rich, gelatinous broth. The vegetables – such as carrots, turnips, onions and potatoes – that are often cooked along with the meat, both add to and take up the dark flavor of the broth. So that meat flavor, the thing that I crave, is everywhere. 

I love to serve pot roast with pureed cauliflower. Just break apart a head of cauliflower into individual florets that are all about the same size. Steam them until they are tender, until they can be easily pierced with a dinner fork. Throw the cooked florets into a food processor with a hunk of butter and some salt and pepper, then serve the puree as you would mashed potatoes. 

I like to pile the puree in a big bowl and surround it with some of the beef and lots of the vegetables that cooked alongside the meat, then drench everything with those amazing cooking juices. Add a hunk of crusty bread for sopping up what you can’t get with your spoon and you have a meal that would satisfy any carnivore. 

And with so much meat flavor, I can satisfy my craving without eating a lot of the meat. 

This recipe is from Martha Stewart’s website, where the lovely and charming Sarah Carey provides a video cooking demonstration using brisket. But really, the recipe is so simple, it practically cooks itself. 



Slow-Cooker Pot Roast 

Serves 8 

1 tablespoon cornstarch 

8 medium carrots, cut into thirds 

2 medium onions, each cut into 8 wedges 

Coarse salt and ground pepper 

1 beef chuck roast (3 pounds), or 1 3-pound beef brisket, trimmed of excess fat 

2 tablespoons Worcestershire sauce (or balsamic or sherry vinegar, or red wine) 

In a slow cooker, stir together the cornstarch and 2 tablespoons of cold water until smooth. Add carrots and onions; season with salt and pepper; place meat on top of vegetables and drizzle with Worcestershire sauce. Cover; cook on high for 6 hours or on low for 10 hours. 

Transfer roast to a cutting board; thinly slice across the grain. (In different sections of the roast, the grain will run in different directions, so pay attention and always slice across the grain for maximum tenderness.) Place vegetables in a serving dish; pour pan juices through a fine-mesh sieve, if desired. (I skip this step, but I do skim off as much fat as possible - there’s lots of it – from the top of the juices.) Serve roast with vegetables and pan juices. 

Share comments and recipes at

Reader Comments


For a really super bowl, start with Cincinnati Sans Carne

This vegetarian take on a traditional, spicy Cincinnati Chili uses mushrooms instead of meat, and spaghetti squash instead of spaghetti.

North African spices, heat add zip to butternut stew

The gentle thickening with cornstarch created a wonderfully silky sauce, and the squash retained it shape and texture.

Pork pie recipe forges a new path to a delicious tradition

This quest was passed to my brothers who, in turn, tried their hand at creating that most elusive, perfect meat pie, the one from our childhood, the one to which all others must be compared.

World peace just may start with pie

If John Kerry called and asked me to help end Syria's civil war, I'd bring this coconut custard pie.

Sausage gravy: It's beginning to smell a lot like Christmas

My favorite recipe calls for an extra shot of poultry seasoning and hits of nutmeg and hot sauce in the gravy, suspending the sausage in a creamy, decadent blanket of Christmas.

Aunt Iris' penuche — brown sugar fudge that makes one sweet gift

With a butterscotch and subtle maple flavor, it's so decadently sweet, really just a lump of sugar studded with toasty walnuts, but it's so delicious.

In Turkey Tetrazzini, Thanksgiving leftovers go from burden to blessing

It combines common holiday leftovers with some delicious add-ins to create a dish you can freeze, then, sometime in January, bake and enjoy the delayed fruits of your labor.

New meets old in a pie made with squash and oatmeal

Butternut squash pie seems to have fallen by the wayside but when I was a kid, we never ate pumpkin pie. It was always squash.

Feeding the wild vegetarian at your holiday table

You don't have to shove tradition aside entirely, you just have to add some delicious food that doesn't contain meat, and some other great meatless dishes that don't call for dairy products.